November 2018 AOR - Join here

[SithLord]

?? They give refusals after all this wait without even sending a PFL??

I'm not at all surprised after all that I went through with my application.

I'm kind of happy they atleast refused now and didn't prolong it to 2020.

 

[SithLord]

Unbelievable! I hope this situation gets resolved at the earliest. Did your gcms notes reflect any of these concerns ?

Ironically, gcms says they verified my employer through phone call and I appear met lol

 

[SithLord]

Hey Sith,

I have found out the circulars which could be useful in claiming that you were tax exempted.

Please attach the pdfs of the circulars from the below link.

For ITR circulars - https://incometaxindia.gov.in/Pages/communications/circulars.aspx
Notice for 2017 ITR - https://incometaxindia.gov.in/communications/circular/circular29_2017.pdf

Will pray for you.
Good Luck.

Thank you so much. Been receiving a lot of support which is nice to see.

 

[Chee]

Not the news that anyone wants to hear, just woke up to a refusal.

1) PG Diploma was missing from WES Summary so the officer concluded I do not have two degrees.
2) Officer was not satisfied I worked for the employer I declared since I didn't provide IT returns. I had a low salary so I was tax exempt. My employer provided with a salary certificate mentioning I was tax exempt, payslips but still employer was not convinced.
3) Gift deed was not accepted even though the funds has been sitting in my account for more than a year collecting interest.

Oh well back to the good old Ray of Hope days

it is sad to hear how can they be so silent for long and just reject raise request again for appeal through lawyer ...... Did you get any ADR in between

 

[Asher7]

Ironically, gcms says they verified my employer through phone call and I appear met lol

You’ve always been helpful to me and were the only one to answer my questions when I posted a query. I’m feeling really bad. This is unprecedented.. I’m a lawyer and will ask around, including my cousin in Canada to see what all can be done. There have been cases where they first refuse and then approve an application. I’m certain that this will be resolved.

 

[scargee]

Not the news that anyone wants to hear, just woke up to a refusal.

1) PG Diploma was missing from WES Summary so the officer concluded I do not have two degrees.
2) Officer was not satisfied I worked for the employer I declared since I didn't provide IT returns. I had a low salary so I was tax exempt. My employer provided with a salary certificate mentioning I was tax exempt, payslips but still employer was not convinced.
3) Gift deed was not accepted even though the funds has been sitting in my account for more than a year collecting interest.

Oh well back to the good old Ray of Hope days

Omg! Please hire a lawyer! This is really unacceptable! Took 10 mos and then refusal? Thats BS!

 

[united555]

Thank you so much. Been receiving a lot of support which is nice to see.

I think it was that specific officer!!! Any other officer would have approved your application! I am certain that they reconsider their decision with a new officer

 

[SithLord]

Omg! Please hire a lawyer! This is really unacceptable! Took 10 mos and then refusal? Thats BS!

Well I entered into the pool again as back up and trying to collect documents for reconsideration. Let's see!!

Thanks!!!

 

[SithLord]

I think it was that specific officer!!! Any other officer would have approved your application! I am certain that they reconsider their decision with a new officer

It could be a first in Canadian Immigration history to get a refusal after receiving a positive verification from employer

Is reconsideration actually reviewed by a different officer?

I seriously expected a procedural fairness letter atleast at this point.

 

[scargee]

Well I entered into the pool again as back up and trying to collect documents for reconsideration. Let's see!!

Thanks!!!

Appeal your case and I hope they reopen and reconsider. That's insane man. They should've done it earlier. It's the agony of waiting that's making me mad about this. Only to be refused. That's really disappointing.

 

[matekaran]

No ban. They were not convinced for both proof of employment and funds.

I will make an appeal to have my case reconsidered after collecting more documents[/


Did you submit everything on your own or hired any consultancy or pr lawyer when applying for Express Entry?

 

[Villegas Family]

Well I entered into the pool again as back up and trying to collect documents for reconsideration. Let's see!!

Thanks!!!

Appeal appeal appeal! Get a lawyer or legal consultation. I have heard of cases refused, and then quickly approved when appealed appropriately. You have not misrepresented yourself and an officer with some sense will pass you!

 

[matekaran]

It could be a first in Canadian Immigration history to get a refusal after receiving a positive verification from employer

Is reconsideration actually reviewed by a different officer?

I seriously expected a procedural fairness letter atleast at this point.

Did you submit everything on your own or hired any consultancy or pr lawyer when applying for Express Entry?

 

[rob-immigrationstory]

Not gonna lie, I was silently rooting for you @SithLord due to you being so active on the forum. Sorry to hear that

 

[dry.00]

It could be a first in Canadian Immigration history to get a refusal after receiving a positive verification from employer

Is reconsideration actually reviewed by a different officer?

I seriously expected a procedural fairness letter atleast at this point.

I think you should consult a lawyer before making any moves.
I'm sorry to hear about the bad news...I hope everything goes well for you in the future.

Now I'm anxious about my application, even though I included pay slips and had no gift deeds