DENIED

[kcward7]

Ive been told by Immigration that they don’t recommend him to leave the country until he gets the PR.
I’ve asked them two years ago, when my father in law in Budapest asked to see his son at his death bed.
After that I’ve asked many times only to get the same answer

Like I said it sounds like this is largely irrelevant now. If what needs to happen is for him to return to get necessary documentation to reapply, you'll need to make that decision. If you're concerned about travel while an application is in progress you should consider reapplying outland when you have the documentation that you need (no work permit option available with the outland stream).

I'm not sure exactly what steps you took - if you applied for spousal sponsorship inland with the OWP, there was nothing preventing him from leaving.
Your concern likely comes from the fact that CBSA reserves the right to deny him re-entry and if this was the case, the application would be abandoned. That said, inland applicants take short trips and face no issues returning to Canada pending they meet admissibility requirements.

 

[ryester]

Ive been told by Immigration that they don’t recommend him to leave the country until he gets the PR.
I’ve asked them two years ago, when my father in law in Budapest asked to see his son at his death bed.
After that I’ve asked many times only to get the same answer

Did you ask IRCC or your lawyer? I would not imagine IRCC would give you this answer. You lawyer may say it based on his cases and experiences. But remember every case is different in immigration, nobody can guarantee anything.

If you are not comfortable to let your husband go back to collect the document now, I would suggest to wait until his working visa expires and then go back to collect the documents he needs for spousal visa. Who knows, maybe his ex would agree to let the kids do the medical in the middle of waiting.

 

[Londonfog.2413]

Thanks for advising me. I truly appreciate your help.
Immigration it’s a nightmare lol
I will talk to my husband about him going very soon.
Yes you are right, we are terrified of them don’t allow him back.
I

 

[Londonfog.2413]

I’ve asked them over and over
“We do not recommend the client to leave the country until he obtains his PR”

 

[kcward7]

Pardon my French but fuck yeah I’ve asked them over and over
“We do not advise for the client to leave the country until he obtains his PR”

http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/helpcentre/answer.asp?qnum=248&top=28

Again, you need to make sure you have all the proper documentation if you plan to reapply.

 

[Londonfog.2413]

OMG OMG This is gold!!!!!!!! How could the lawyers overview THIS!!!!’
I’m so very thankful for this, I’ll go to the library to print it right now!!!
THANKS, HUGE THANKS!!!!!!

 

[kcward7]

OMG OMG This is gold!!!!!!!! How could the lawyers overview THIS!!!!’
I’m so very thankful for this, I’ll go to the library to print it right now!!!
THANKS, HUGE THANKS!!!!!!

I don't know what printing for your lawyers is going to do but like I said above: they are right in saying there is a risk of leaving the country with an inland app in progress. Just so we're clear. If an applicant left and was denied re-entry (which is possible) the application will be abandoned.

 

[Londonfog.2413]

I’ve meant to say I will show this to our lawyer and MP tomorrow

 

[np08]

OMG OMG This is gold!!!!!!!! How could the lawyers overview THIS!!!!’
I’m so very thankful for this, I’ll go to the library to print it right now!!!
THANKS, HUGE THANKS!!!!!!

This isn't really new information, though. "Not advised" doesn't mean not allowed period or that he will 100% be refused entry upon return. He's from a visa exempt country - the chances of a refused entry are quite low and this is something that happens very rarely. It's not advised for people to leave during the process because it's better to be safe than sorry, and the risk is always there, no matter how small. I'm personally of the opinion that leaving for a vacation or random family visits is foolish and playing with fire for no reason.

But if something important like this happens, of course the applicant should go. Especially with the alternative being a refused application.

 

[kcward7]

I’ve meant to say I will show this to our lawyer and MP tomorrow

I understand, my point is I don't see how that changes anything about your situation. The link is shared with you isn't new, and can be easily found. If you're still interested in pursuing PR I would be looking at getting all documentation required and reapplying (making sure you choose the stream that best suits your situation).

Good Luck.

 

[Londonfog.2413]

This isn't really new information, though. "Not advised" doesn't mean not allowed period or that he will 100% be refused entry upon return. He's from a visa exempt country - the chances of a refused entry are quite low and this is something that happens very rarely. It's not advised for people to leave during the process because it's better to be safe than sorry, and the risk is always there, no matter how small. I'm personally of the opinion that leaving for a vacation or random family visits is foolish and playing with fire for no reason.

But if something important like this happens, of course the applicant should go. Especially with the alternative being a refused application.

 

[Londonfog.2413]

Absolutely they will know his application was denied last week.
What could happen then?

 

[kcward7]

Absolutely they will know his application was denied last week.
What could happen then?

What do you mean what could happen then?

 

[np08]

Absolutely they will know his application was denied last week.
What could happen then?

Who will know? What will happen with what?

 

[Londonfog.2413]

What do you mean what could happen then?

What could happen once they see this info at the airport in Vancouver?